• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Menu
  • Home
  • About
    • About Franchise Chatter
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Service
    • Affiliate Disclosures
  • Subscribers Hub
    • Login
    • New to Franchise Chatter? Start Here
    • America’s Most Lucrative Franchises
    • Franchises Ranked by Average Revenues
    • Franchises Ranked by Average Profits
    • Franchise Winners, Survivors and Losers Last Year
    • FDD Talk
    • Search by Name
  • Top Franchises
  • Franchise Earnings
  • Costs
  • Fees
  • Quiz
  • Search

U.S. Court of Appeals Affirms Decision in Favor of UPS in Lawsuit Filed by UPS Store Franchisees

Last updated on December 16, 2011 by Franchise Chatter 3 Comments
in Franchise News, Shipping Franchise

In March 2006, approximately 200 UPS Store franchisees sued UPS for alleged violations of the California Franchise Investment Law (“CFIL”) and common law fraud and misrepresentations, among other causes of action.  The franchisees claimed that UPS made false statements and omissions of material facts in various communications made in connection with the conversion from the Mailboxes Etc. (MBE) franchise model to the new UPS Store franchise model.

In a decision handed down last week, the Court of Appeals affirmed the earlier decision of the District Court in favor of UPS on the grounds that the UPS Store franchisees failed to present any evidence that they relied on the alleged untrue or misleading statements of the company. L. Michael Hankes, lead counsel representing the franchisees, said they are filing a motion for reconsideration.

The UPS Store Photo by KT of Lake Orion



Learn Which Franchises Can Make You Rich
For those unfamiliar, UPS acquired MBE in 2001 and made no changes to the franchise name and business model during the first couple years.  At that time, MBE franchisees offered their customers a variety of shipping options, including UPS, FedEx, DHL, and USPS, and could set their own retail rates for shipping, just like other owners of independent shipping stores.  Since MBE franchisees were not getting meaningful discounts from the shippers, they were charging their own customers such high prices that package volumes were suffering.

Sometime in 2002, UPS tested new, low retail rates in a few cities across the country under 3 different brand names: MBE, UPS Mailboxes Etc., and The UPS Store.  With The UPS Stores faring the best, this limited test run became the basis for the Gold Shield Program, which most MBE franchisees accepted. Under the program, franchisees lost the ability to set their own UPS retail rates but in exchange, they received far better incentives from UPS than any other retail outlet.

America's Most Lucrative Franchises of the Year

I heard about this franchisee lawsuit when I was still a UPS Store owner back in 2006.  While I’m sympathetic to their cause, I was skeptical they could prove their case of fraud against UPS.  Although I feel bad for the franchisees for waiting all these years only to have their claims denied, if you’re going to file a case against one of the biggest, most respected companies on the planet, you better have rock solid evidence to back it up.

My main beef with UPS is that they are using the stores as glamorized drop off locations, while compensating the franchisees very little for these drop off packages.  Frustrating? Yes. Infuriating? Yes. Sufficient cause of action for a lawsuit? Sadly, no.

I was secretly hoping that the franchisees had some sort of smoking gun that would force UPS to modify the franchise business model to something more equitable for the owners.  But according to the courts, the franchisees failed to prove that they relied on misleading statements and omissions of UPS when they chose to participate in the Gold Shield Program. The franchisees who filed this lawsuit are assumed to be well informed individuals who can make reasonable business decisions.  Without solid proof of fraud, this outcome is hardly surprising.


🎯Find Good Franchises That Are Still AVAILABLE in Your Target Area (Free Tool)



💻How to Find, Vet, FUND & Own a Good Franchise. Watch Our Free Webinar Live or the Recording Later



💰How Much Franchise Can You AFFORD? Use Our Free Financial Calculator



Franchises Ranked by Average Revenues and Profits



Franchise Winners and Losers Last Year

Tagged as: The UPS Store

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. bill says

    June 20, 2012 at 1:46 pm

    your dead wrong, they use misleading statements right from the start…………..they tell you…. you own your business and then make you sign a 10 year lease…leasing is not owning………it is false advertising right from the start

    Reply
    • Franchise Chatter says

      June 20, 2012 at 3:04 pm

      Hi Bill,

      If you’ve read my previous posts on my UPS Store experience, you’ll know that I had so many complaints against UPS (the flawed business model, not compensating the stores fairly for drop offs, competing directly against the stores). But one of the good things was that I was able to get a good return on my investment when I sold my store. The fact that I was able to sell my store means that I owned it.

      Best regards,

      Ambrosio

      Reply
  2. Bill says

    January 23, 2013 at 3:40 pm

    try again……….when you lease you dont own…end of story…..can a lease be sold, yes…if it is in the contract……

    i am not saying UPS shouldnt be able to sell their leases, but they are falsely advertising……..there is not one aspect of the UPS Store that even remotely represents owning our business

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Previous post: CareMinders Home Care's Aggressive Franchise Growth Strategy Projects 100 New Franchises Within 2 Years

Next post: Exclusive Q&A with Bob Watson, CEO of 5 & Diner ("We've developed a new prototype that is less expensive to build but can serve the same number of customers.")

Primary Sidebar

💵Most Profitable Franchises of 2023

💻How to Find, Vet, FUND & Own a Good Franchise (Webinar)

✅ Is Franchising a Path for You? – Feb. 3 (Fri.), 11 a.m. EST

✅ Hall of Fame Franchises – Feb. 7 (Tues.), 4 p.m. EST

✅ Register Now to Get Free Access to Recordings of Both Webinars

Register Now

🎯Find Good Franchises That Are Still AVAILABLE in Your Target Area (Free Tool)

⭐️Franchise Chatter is reader-supported. We may receive a commission for leads generated from our site.

As seen in:  New York Times, Bloomberg Businessweek, and CNBC

Login

Remember Me
Register | Lost your Password?
Reminder: Your username and password are case-sensitive.

Need help? Email franchisechatterblog@gmail.com

👍”Your website and you have been instrumental in finding this franchise opportunity and I am overwhelmingly grateful.” (David F., subscriber)

🏆 Best Franchises by Industry

Best Franchises by Industry (All Lists)

Best Gym and Fitness Franchises

Best Pizza Franchises

Best Sandwich Franchises

Best Childcare Franchises

Best Ice Cream Franchises

Best Coffee Franchises

Best Hamburger Franchises

Best Salon and Beauty Franchises

Best Chicken Franchises

Best Smoothie and Juice Franchises

Best Maid Service Franchises

Best Mexican Restaurant Franchises

Best Massage Service Franchises

Best Tutoring Franchises

Best Auto Repair Franchises

Best Auto Oil Change Franchises

Best Asian Restaurant Franchises

Best Pet Franchises

Best Commercial Cleaning Franchises

Best Sports Bar Franchises

Best Baked Goods Franchises

Best Moving/Junk Removal Franchises

Best Mailbox Franchises

Best Apparel Retail Franchises

Best Senior Care Franchises

Best Restoration Franchises

Best Tech Franchises

Best Travel Agency Franchises

Best Trampoline Park Franchises

Best Tools Distribution Franchises

Best Property Management Franchises

Best Real Estate Franchises

Best Automotive Wheels and Tires Franchises

Best Weight Loss Franchises

Best Flooring Franchises

Best Eye Care Franchises

Best Physical Therapy Franchises

Best CBD Franchises

Best Tea Franchises

Best Ghost Kitchen Franchises

Best Acai Bowl Franchises

Best Poké Bowl Franchises

Best Donut Franchises

Best Kitchen and Bath Remodeling Franchises

Best Window Coverings Franchises

Best Plumbing Franchises

Best Home Inspection Franchises

Best Garage Franchises

Best Barbershop Franchises

Best Laundromat Franchises

Best Storage Unit Franchises

Best Car Wash Service Franchises

🚀 Daily FDD Talk Posts

UFC Gym Franchise

Sola Salons Franchise

N-Hance Wood Refinishing Franchise

Cost Cutters Franchise

Ziggi’s Coffee Franchise

D1 Training Franchise

Soccer Shots Franchise

Batteries Plus Franchise

STRIDE Fitness Franchise

Expense Reduction Analysts Franchise

HouseMaster Home Inspections Franchise

Homewatch CareGivers Franchise

Central Bark Franchise

ActionCOACH Franchise

Junk King Franchise

BrightStar Care Franchise

Restoration 1 Franchise

Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory Franchise

Bodybar Pilates Franchise

Bloomin’ Blinds Franchise

Spavia Day Spa Franchise

Costa Oil Franchise

Amada Senior Care Franchise

Camp Bow Wow Franchise

McAlister’s Deli Franchise

Zaxby’s Franchise

Zoom Room Franchise

Urban Air Adventure Park Franchise

Wetzel’s Pretzels Franchise

Rumble Franchise

HomeWell Care Services Franchise

Smoothie King Franchise

Right at Home Franchise

Meineke Franchise

Fetch! Pet Care Franchise

The Human Bean Franchise

Bojangles Franchise

ServiceMaster Restore Franchise

Assisted Living Locators Franchise

Spray-Net Franchise

barre3 Franchise

ComForCare Home Care Franchise

Archadeck Outdoor Living Franchise

Midas Franchise

Visiting Angels Franchise

Cousins Subs Franchise

Door Renew Franchise

Chicken Salad Chick Franchise

Franchise Chatter © 2023