• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Menu
  • Home
  • About
    • About Franchise Chatter
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Service
    • Affiliate Disclosures
  • Subscribers Only
    • Login
    • New to Franchise Chatter? Start Here
    • America’s Most Lucrative Franchises
    • Franchises Ranked by Average Revenues
    • Franchises Ranked by Average Profits
    • Franchise Winners, Survivors and Losers Last Year
    • FDD Talk
    • Search by Name
  • Top Franchises
  • Franchise Earnings
  • Costs
  • Fees
  • Quiz
  • Search

2012 Top 100 AllBusiness AllStar Franchises Revealed; Methodology Favors a Particular Class of Franchisors

Last updated on December 17, 2011 by Franchise Chatter 5 Comments
in Best of List, Franchise Commentary

While I’m an avid follower of lists of all kinds, I hardly ever take the time to read the methodology behind them as I tend to accept things at face value.  But in my new role as a franchise blogger and as someone who has attempted to put together a list of my own, I’m curious how more established media organizations come up with their annual rankings of the year’s best.

AllBusiness.com, an online resource for small business and a wholly-owned subsidiary of Dun & Bradstreet (a company that provides information on businesses and corporations for use in credit decisions, B2B marketing and supply chain management), recently released their list of 100 AllBusiness AllStar Franchises for 2012.  Their criteria for selecting the winners are:  franchise unit growth rate, financial strength, system size, years in business and years franchising, and Web (brand) visibility.

  • Growth rank received the highest weighting.  AllBusiness looked at the change in the number of franchise units over three years, with U.S.-based growth more heavily weighted than international or conversion-unit growth, and the most recent year’s growth more heavily weighted than growth in earlier years.
  • Financial strength rank is based on D&B’s predictive Commercial Credit and Financial Stress Scores (The latter score was given a higher weighting).
  • System size rank measures the size of the franchise system. AllBusiness assigned points based on different weightings for the number of U.S.-based franchise units (heaviest weighting), company-owned units, and non-U.S.-based units (lightest weighting).
  • Longevity rank compares how long a franchise company has been around. AllBusiness assigned points based on the number of years a franchise company has been in business and how many years it has been franchising (The latter number was given a higher weighting).
  • Web visibility rank is based on a franchise website’s Google PageRank and Alexa Traffic Rank.

Subway Sandwich Photo by Fred @ SG



Learn Which Franchises Can Make You Rich
The focus of this AllBusiness ranking is the stability of the franchisor, without any consideration given to the health of its franchisees.  Implicit in this methodology is the view that a franchisor can only succeed for a sustained period of time if its franchisees are also doing well.  While there is good reason for this line of thinking, the list heavily favors franchise companies that are already big and established, while up-and-coming brands with excellent unit economics are shut out completely.

America's Most Lucrative Franchises of the Year

Moreover, a franchise that is growing rapidly may be great for the franchisor, but overexpansion can be devastating for the individual unit.  Cold Stone Creamery and Quizno’s are two brands that have suffered in recent years because they grew too fast (in my opinion).

Should a prospective owner select a franchise opportunity based solely on the health of the franchisor?  I don’t think so.  While this is a critical factor, it certainly doesn’t paint the entire picture.  (In fairness to AllBusiness, all lists have their inherent limitations, and this particular list is superior to most because it’s based on objective and clearly defined metrics.) Let’s treat this list as a small piece of a much larger puzzle, and use it accordingly.

Here are the Top 25 AllBusiness AllStar Franchises of 2012.  To read the entire list, please click here.

1.   Subway – brand awareness (#1), growth (#14)
2.   7-Eleven – longevity (#6), brand awareness (#3), growth (#19)
3.   Jimmy John’s Gourmet Sandwich Shops – growth (#16), financial strength (#20), Web visibility (#7)
4.   Dunkin Donuts – brand awareness (#5), Web visibility (#20), growth (#12)
5.   Kumon North America – brand awareness (#13), Web visibility (#34), financial strength (#38)
6.   Marco’s Pizza – financial strength (#4), growth (#29)
7.   Papa John’s International – growth (#25), financial strength (#49)
8.   Great Clips – brand awareness (#19), growth (#33), Web visibility (#48), financial strength (#48)
9.   Anytime Fitness – growth (#10), financial strength (#31)
10.  Aaron’s Sales & Lease Ownership – financial strength (#23), brand awareness (#32), growth (#39)
11.  Buffalo Wild Wings Grill and Bar
12.  McDonald’s
13.  SERVPRO
14.  Jersey Mike’s Subs
15.  Vanguard Cleaning Systems
16.  Denny’s
17.  Papa Murphy’s
18.  CleanNET USA
19.  Batteries Plus
20.  Domino’s Pizza
21.  Wireless Zone
22.  Hampton Inn / Hampton Inn  & Suites
23.  Plato’s Closet
24.  GNC
25.  Comfort Keepers

🎯Find GOOD Franchises in Your Target Industries That Are STILL Available in Your Area (Free Tool)



💰How Much Franchise Can You Afford? Use Our Free Financial Calculator





Franchise Winners and Losers Last Year

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Eric Stites, Franchise Business Review says

    December 13, 2011 at 5:56 am

    Great point that most franchise rankings DON’T take franchisee performance and franchisee satisfaction into account. That’s why Franchise Business Review bases all our research and annual franchise rankings solely on the feedback from franchisees.Overall satisfaction scores tied to key areas like training and support, franchisee involvement, company values, and financial performance (at the franchisee/unit level) are at the core of our rankings. The only true measure of a franchise business model is how well the system is working for the franchise operators.

    Eric Stites
    Founder and CEO
    http://www.FranchiseBusinessReview.com

    Reply
    • Ambrosio says

      December 13, 2011 at 7:44 am

      Hi Eric,

      Thank you for your comment, and welcome to my blog! So honored to have you here. I’m a big fan of your website. I like your unique approach to franchise rankings by focusing on franchisee satisfaction. Very excited to read who makes it to next year’s lists! Thanks for visiting and hope to see you here again.

      Best regards,

      Ambrosio

      Reply
  2. Nicole Smith says

    December 19, 2011 at 8:21 am

    Eric, I really like your approach. What is your objective evaluation of Kumon North America, thinking of it from the franchisee standpoint? I would very much like to discuss this with you. Ambrosio has been kind enough to feature my views several times on this blog so feel free to have a look at those blogs if you wish.

    Best wishes,

    Nicole

    Reply
  3. Connie Schmidt Kirman says

    December 20, 2011 at 3:23 am

    You have hit the nail on the head! Looking back I was too naive and trusting. Franchisees at the time were very guarded or nervous when asked questions about numbers and profitability. From an outsider with the information around at the time I jumped in thinking it was a good investment of my time and money.

    Although I love what I do, I have two children I need to send to college. I feel for anyone investing in a system that is so one-sided with very limited profitability. Kumon has been growing, but I do believe at the expense of current, hardworking franchisees.

    Please keep evaluating things from the franchisees point of view. People need to know the truth before buying-in.

    Connie Schmidt Kirman
    Kumon Center of Howell

    Reply
  4. Nicole Smith says

    December 20, 2011 at 4:04 am

    Connie, you are a powerhouse. I have learned so much from you about community networking and developing a very challenging market from scratch. Your class has really grown well this year and that is the fruit of all your labours for the past few years. It would be awesome if you could figure out how to work only six days a week, though, and build your profitability to a sustainable level for the needs of your family.

    Warm regards,

    Nicole

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Previous post: Mark Your Calendars for The International Franchise Expo, the Nation's Largest, at The Javits Center in NYC, June 15-17, 2012

Next post: Exclusive Interview with Nick Petti, Founder and CEO of Enviro-Tech Pest Services, an Eco-Friendly Pest Control Franchise

Primary Sidebar

🎯Find GOOD Franchises in Your Target Industries That Are STILL Available in Your Area (Free Tool)

💰How Much Franchise Can You Afford? Use Our Free Financial Calculator

As seen in:  New York Times, Bloomberg Businessweek, and CNBC

Login

Remember Me
Register | Lost your Password?
Reminder: Your username and password are case-sensitive.

Need help? Email franchisechatterblog@gmail.com

🚀 Daily FDD Talk Posts

Jiffy Lube Franchise

DQ Grill & Chill Franchise

College HUNKS Hauling Junk & Moving Franchise

Sport Clips Franchise

QC Kinetix Franchise

Annex Brands Franchise

Steak ‘n Shake Franchise

Garage Force Franchise

Pet Butler Franchise

Kilwins Chocolates Franchise

Matco Tools Franchise

Firehouse Subs Franchise

Mr. Handyman Franchise

GarageExperts Franchise

Tropical Smoothie Cafe Franchise

Moe’s Southwest Grill Franchise

Tim Hortons Franchise

Toppers Pizza Franchise

Sonic Drive-In Franchise

Elements Massage Franchise

Wild Birds Unlimited Franchise

Qdoba Mexican Eats Franchise

Great Harvest Franchise

Snap-On Franchise

Mathnasium Franchise

Beef Jerky Experience Franchise

Ellie Mental Health Franchise

Miracle Method Franchise

LearningRx Franchise

Ellianos Coffee Franchise

The Patch Boys Franchise

Grasons Estate Sales Franchise

Style Encore Franchise

Music Go Round Franchise

Play It Again Sports Franchise

Plato’s Closet Franchise

🏆 Best Franchises by Industry

Best Franchises by Industry (All Lists)

Best Laundromat Franchises

Best Storage Unit Franchises

Best Car Wash Service Franchises

Best Gym and Fitness Franchises

Best Pizza Franchises

Best Sandwich Franchises

Best Childcare Franchises

Best Ice Cream Franchises

Best Coffee Franchises

Best Hamburger Franchises

Best Salon and Beauty Franchises

Best Chicken Franchises

Best Smoothie and Juice Franchises

Best Maid Service Franchises

Best Mexican Restaurant Franchises

Best Massage Service Franchises

Best Tutoring Franchises

Best Auto Repair Franchises

Best Auto Oil Change Franchises

Best Asian Restaurant Franchises

Best Pet Franchises

Best Commercial Cleaning Franchises

Best Sports Bar Franchises

Best Baked Goods Franchises

Best Moving/Junk Removal Franchises

Best Mailbox Franchises

Best Apparel Retail Franchises

Best Senior Care Franchises

Best Restoration Franchises

Best Tech Franchises

Best Travel Agency Franchises

Best Trampoline Park Franchises

Best Tools Distribution Franchises

Best Salon Suites Franchises

Best Property Management Franchises

Best Laboratory Services Franchises

Best Staffing/Recruiting Franchises

Best Real Estate Franchises

Most Profitable Franchises

Top Low Cost Franchises

Franchise Chatter uses affiliate links for Franchise Help and Franchise Brokers Association.

Franchise Chatter © 2022