Earnings Claims of Top Franchises Revealed

Earnings Claims of Top Franchises Revealed

  • Anytime Fitness
  • CruiseOne
  • Firehouse Subs
  • Jimmy John's
  • Massage Envy
  • Menchie's
  • Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt
  • Planet Fitness
  • The UPS Store
  • Yogurt Land
  • And Hundreds More...

No, thanks. I'm not interested in uncovering the actual earnings of hundreds of franchises at this time.

What Sets Menchie’s Apart from Other Frozen Yogurt Franchises?

by Franchise Chatter on May 6, 2011

in Franchise Reviews, Frozen Yogurt Franchises



Franchise Chatter Membership Information

Don't Invest in a Franchise Until You Check Out This List Find the Ideal Business for You

To read dozens of exclusive articles on the frozen yogurt franchise sector, check out our Fro-Yo Files page.

I first came across Menchie’s frozen yogurt franchise when I saw their ad in Franchise Canada magazine earlier this year.  Their ad conveyed a sense of fun and whimsy — with a lot of kid-appeal.  When I went to their website, I learned that their concept is very similar to Yogurtland, which I enjoyed very much when I was in Las Vegas last year.   Menchie’s also offers a variety of yogurt flavors (rotating daily), toppings (fruits, nuts, and candy) and sauces (hot fudge, caramel) in a self-service format where customers pay by weight.

I was so excited to learn that a Western Canadian company called Empire West is planning to open 33 Menchie’s stores in British Columbia and Calgary over the next 5 years.  The press release dated March 15 of this year said that the company is planning to open 3 stores in British Columbia within the next 3 months.  I haven’t seen any signs yet that they are opening in downtown Vancouver, but I’m so looking forward to it eventually happening.  It’s going to be a frequent destination for sure.

Menchie's Photo by Bon Eats



What I admire most about Menchie’s frozen yogurt franchise is their emphasis on providing a great customer experience and creating a family-friendly environment.  The Menchie’s logo makes it very clear that they cater to families with young children — and they seem to be very successful at it.  From all the pictures I’ve seen, their stores are like magnets for kids and teenagers — and their parents don’t seem to mind one bit!  It seems like a place where the entire family can enjoy.

Menchie's Photo by jordymorgan

I’m a big fan of Yogurtland’s selection of flavors because I like original and unexpected flavor combinations.  Yogurtland offers flavors like Chocolate Coconut Truffle, Devil’s Food Cupcake Batter, and Key Lime Bar Tart.   On the other hand, Menchie’s offerings are more traditional —   like chocolate, pistachio, cookies and cream, and countless fruit flavors.  But what I do like about Menchie’s frozen yogurt is their wide selection of low-carb, no sugar, and dairy-free options — giving me the option to be naughty or nice depending on my mood.

Menchie's Photo by Bon Eats

What strikes me as most impressive about Menchie’s frozen yogurt franchise is their explosive growth.  They’ve only been in business since 2007 and began franchising in 2008.  They now have over 70 franchise stores operating in the US, with many more opening soon.  They are also expanding internationally to countries like Canada, Mexico, China, Japan, Australia, India, and the United Kingdom, among others.

Menchie's Photo by jordymorgan

The total initial investment for a Menchie’s frozen yogurt franchise ranges from $241,537 to $574,537 (with the average coming in between $340,000 to $400,000).  The franchise fee is $40,000 and ongoing royalty is 6% of gross sales.  The minimum net worth requirement is $100,000 in cash and the ability to finance the rest.

Menchie's Photo by vivalahannah

The frozen yogurt business is one where having a well known (and, hopefully, well loved) brand really makes a difference.  An independent mom-and-pop frozen yogurt place will have a hard time competing with a brand that has a loyal fan base.  I’ve seen independent stores struggle because they can’t seem to recreate the same environment and experience that a well financed chain can.

And Menchie’s frozen yogurt in particular seems to attract a lot of celebrity customers — like Taylor Swift and Selena Gomez to name a few — and this certainly enhances  the appeal of the brand, especially with the younger crowd.



Menchie's Photo by Bon Eats

My only concern is whether this whole frozen yogurt trend is just a fad.  There was a time when Krispy Kreme was the hottest food concept around.  But because they saturated the market by making their products available in so many locations (like convenience stores), their brand quickly lost its luster.  Competing in this sector are many players like Pinkberry, Red Mango, Yogen Fruz, and Yogurtland — each just a little bit different from the other.  In the end, only a few companies will thrive.   My bet is on the self-service concepts like Menchie’s and Yogurtland because they offer not just a good product but a fun experience as well.

I think Menchie’s frozen yogurt will be a fun franchise to own.  Seeing people have a good time while enjoying my products and environment will be satisfying on so many levels, I’m sure.  When I used to own a UPS Store, one of my pet peeves was having to put out fires when UPS didn’t deliver customers’ packages on time, or worse, delivered them broken.  It would be so nice to own a place that brings joy to people and enables me to earn a good living at the same time.  I think Menchie’s frozen yogurt has the potential to make both possible.



Franchise Matching Quiz



{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

Elthia Tolentino October 5, 2011 at 1:27 am

I enjoyed the first taste (and last) I had of Menchie yoghurt a couple of weeks ago. Recently, we went to CA and my husband’s friend took us to Menchine in Canoga Park, CA after having dinner at nearby restaurant. I was surprised with my self that I finished the full tub of yoghurt with 3 flavours I chose and lots of topping, as well. I did not realise the cost would be on weight. I just saw my husband’s friend paid the tab at the counter, with them less than half in their cup. Anyway, I enjoyed every minute of eating the yoghurt. Can’t wait for Menchie to be available in Sydney, Australia. Thank you!!!

Reply

Ambrosio October 5, 2011 at 2:33 am

Hi Elthia,

Thank you for your comment on Menchie’s! I haven’t been to a Menchie’s yet, so I’m very excited for the first Vancouver location to open sometime this fall. I’ll definitely be a frequent visitor as I love the self-serve format. When I was in Vegas last year, I was able to try Yogurtland, and absolutely loved it! Hope Sydney gets its own Menchie’s or Yogurtland store soon!

Ambrosio

Reply

Vivian March 14, 2012 at 8:55 pm

A Menchie’s recently opened in my area in Toronto. My daughter absolutely loves it. We went there on various days and at times during the week. There seemed to be a steady stream of customers each time we stayed there. I am currently considering opening a Menchie’s in the Greater Toronto Area. My friends living in LA also did a “consumer report” on a Menchie’s vs. a Yogurtland in their area. They both prefer the taste and atmosphere at Menchie’s. However, on of my concern ist the impact of the cooler climate and longer winter Toronto has on the business. I’d like to get some opinion on that.

Thanks,
Vivian

Reply

Ambrosio March 16, 2012 at 11:06 pm

Hi Vivian,

Frozen yogurt shops tend to do better in more temperate climates, so opening in Toronto requires careful market research. I would look into how the ice cream shops and other frozen dessert places are doing in the Greater Toronto area during the winter. How is customer traffic at the indoor malls? You will do gangbusters during the summer, but will it be enough to tide you over during the long winter? You mentioned that a Menchie’s recently opened in your area in Toronto, and it seems to be doing well. That is certainly an encouraging sign, but more research is needed.

Any thoughts from those who live in cities with long winters?

Best regards,

Ambrosio

Reply

Ambrosio March 19, 2012 at 2:00 am

Hi Vivian,

Please check out my new interview (posted March 19) with the CEO of TCBY. He makes some interesting statements on how TCBY is doing in regions with colder climates.

Best regards,

Ambrosio

Reply

Greg October 24, 2011 at 10:39 am

Freshberry is a better quality and tasting yogurt. I’ve been to Menchie’s and if you are looking for a clean experience, this isn’t it. They use Yo Cream and anyone can get it. Look long and hard before picking a franchise.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: